444 S. Washington Street
New Bremen, OH 45869
Susan Krieg

There’s a simple lesson from childhood we all remember quite vividly: “It’s what’s inside that counts.” Until you’ve had the chance to sample some of the delectable morsels available from The Pie Shell in the community of New Bremen, Ohio you’ll never know how true that is.

​Susan Krieg is the owner of The Pie Shell, and the whiz behind everything from the flaky crust of one of her 36 varieties of pie to the buttercream frosting clinging scrumptiously to one of the many kinds of cakes she whips up daily.

​Each dessert is made with consistent care. All of her pastries, cakes, frosting and even cookies are made from scratch. She loves to make and create something that makes people happy.

​If you’re looking for tasty, decadent dessert to finish off any meal or add that certain something to an event, wedding or special occasion; look no further than The Pie Shell. You can order pies, cakes, cookies and cheesecakes.  Stop in at WAGNER’S IGA in New Bremen to see what’s available.



July 2015 The Pie Shell was recognized by the office of Secretary of State, Jon Husted, as part of the monthly 'Ohio Business Profile'. For more about The Pie Shell's recognition by the Secretary of State's office, check out the Patriotic Pride segment on the SOS Facebook page.

February 2014  The Pie Shell became available at all 3 Wagner's IGA locations.

November 2013  Susan moved her home-base business into Wagner's IGA New Bremen. 

September 2010  Susan was part of the team of New Bremen Giant Pumpkin Growers who broke the previously held Guinness Book of World Record of the largest pumpkin pie (3,699 lbs) and 20 feet in diameter.

August 2005  After providing a local restaurant a few pies a week, The Pie Shell was born.

July 2004  Susan entered a pie contest, earning 2nd place.